Can Donors Buy Their Way Into a Job in a University's Athletic Department? It Just Happened....
Thu, 2007-02-15 00:45 — Berger
Every day college athletics resembles professional sports more and more. With billions of dollars being spent on facilities, equipment, marketing efforts, broadcasting contracts and recruiting, there is a fine line between the amateur level and the pro level. Heck, the NCAA grossed more money in 2004 than the NBA did.
Today we find out that the University of Oregon has hired alumnus and key donor Pat Kilkenny as the school's new athletic director. Kilkenny is the former chairman and majority shareholder of San Diego based Arrowhead General Insurance Agency. He sold the company last year.
I can live with the fact that Oregon wanted to think "outside the box" when searching for an AD to replace outgoing AD Bill Moos, who reportedly wasn't on the same page as Oregon's sugar daddy, Phil Knight. The university wanted someone who could get along with their donors and take their facilities and athletic development to the next level.
Here's where things get a bit weird though. Kilkenny has ZERO experience running an athletic department. Its great that he can fundraise and is a solid businessman, but there is much more to running an athletic department. The other odd thing about this hiring is that sources tell me that during Oregon's search for an AD, the search committee told prospective candidates that the university was only interested in candidates with Division I AD experience on their resume. Hmm.
Kilkenny put up much of the funding for the nearly $2 million settlement agreement with outgoing Oregon athletic director Bill Moos. ÂÂ
Kilkenny has also been a key donor in the university's stalled arena project. A project that has not gotten the buy in from Phil Knight...yet. I have no doubt with Kilkenny leading the charge that he'll rally Knight and the other donors to raise the money needed to build the new arena.
To get the ball rolling, Kilkenny has even paid $1.5 million in planning costs for the proposed basketball arena to replace McArthur Court.
Some people might even say that the relationship between Pat Kilkenny and the man who hired him, University of Oregon President David Frohnmayer goes beyond the typical donor - university President relationship. If you look at Kilkenny's bio on the Arrowhead General website it mentions that one of the major recipients of funding from Kilkenny's AGIA Foundation is the Fanconi Anemia Research Fund...which just happens to be founded by the Frohnmayers. Intriguing.
Kilkenny may be just the guy to lead the University of Oregon's Athletic Department where it needs to go in the next two years, but to say his hiring isn't surprising would be an understatement. You could also throw in the word "alarming".
Kilkenny has agreed to a two-year pact, the salary for which he will donate back to the university. That money amounted to $166,385 under predecessor Bill Moos in the most recent calendar year. Nice gesture and fitting for a multi-millionaire.
My main concern is this. Will Kilkenny's hiring start a trend? More and more athletic departments are being run like Fortune 500 companies anyways, so will university Presidents start hiring multi-millionaire donors in order to have those donors bring in other donors and more dollars and thus develop better facilities, better brand awareness and ultimately an athletic department that will be a cash cow? This doesn't sound at all like amateur athletics to me. And guess who will call the shots in that scenario? It certainly won't be the university Presidents - it will be the donors writing those big checks who will essentially own the athletic department - inside and out.
For anyone who doesn't think that university donors call the shots, just look at this hiring today. It used to be that the donors worked behind the scenes and simply wrote the checks. Now they're sitting in the AD's office in the driver's seat with the keys to the athletic department.

Delicious
Reddit
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Check out John Canzano's
Check out John Canzano's article today in the Oregonian:
http://www.oregonlive.com/sports/oregonian/john_canzano/index.ssf?/base/sports/1171513512149260.xml&coll=7
Kilkenny was blatantly hired simply to get a new arena built in the next two years, and then he can ride off into the sunset, known as the savior of UO basketball. This has Phil Knight's pawprints all over it.
No doubt the hiring of Pat
No doubt the hiring of Pat Kilkenny raises some eyebrows but at the same the guy loves the University and could earn a lot more money in the private sector. My guess is that the new basketball arena will get built, which is sorely needed. Fundraising outside of the arena project will also increase. I have a hard time seeing the downside of this. Kilkenny's contract is for two years. He'll probably step down after that if the new arena is well on it's way to completion. Oregon is one of the few schools in the country that has a self-sufficient athletic department.
The downside that I see here
The downside that I see here is the precedent that the hiring sets -- what qualifications does Kilkenny have in running an athletic department? Read this sample job description for an AD: "The director of athletics reports to the president and is responsible for planning, budgeting, developing and directing all intercollegiate athletic programs and activities. The director of athletics is expected to provide leadership necessary to achieve a successful athletic program, ensure compliance to all governing authorities and establish a strong and positive presence at the local, regional and national levels. The position requires an individual who is an effective and articulate leader who will represent intercollegiate athletics in the community, the ABC Conference and other external areas. The successful candidate will have an understanding of the role of intercollegiate athletics in American higher education; a record of success and progressive responsibility as a Division I administrator; thorough knowledge of NCAA regulations, requirements and reporting systems." Its more than just shaking hands and going to pancake breakfasts at the local Lions Club meeting....
Post new comment